ON THE LEVEL January, 2000
Members demand democratic right to decide their own structure
Council appeals to BC Labour Board
Nor Cal member expelled over wildcat protest
Market Share a disastrous term for Union
Strike and Boycott information
PRESIDENT’S CORNER by Len Embree
The School of the Americas Protest by John Voykin Local 2300
COUNCIL COMMENT by Dave Flynn
WTO — Not good for working families
Canadian Brickies apply for successorship rights in Ontario
Millwrights offer trades upgrading
Members demand democratic right to decide their own structure
McCarron threatens to merge Island Locals

The fight has begun. On December 7, 1999, a faxed letter from General President Douglas McCarron announced his latest attack on the BC membership. The letter, sent to Vancouver Island locals, proclaimed the dissolving of three locals and the transferring of their books, assets etc. to three other Island locals. Transferring locals without membership approval was rejected by the BC membership in a recent referendum.
McCarron's proposal ignores labour history in British Columbia and will probably be ruled illegal under BC labour law.
In his decree merging Port Alberni Local 513 into Nanaimo Local 527, Duncan Local 1812 into Victoria Local 1598, and Powell River Local 2068 into North Island Local 1989, McCarron talks about the "full and fair opportunity (that) has been extended to the membership and to their local leadership to participate in the consultation process."
McCarron says he has determined that "it would be in the best interest of the United Brotherhood" to dissolve Locals 513, 1812 and 2068 effective January 4, 2000 and transfer their property and assets to the remaining locals "as soon as possible."
This flies in the face of the results of the so-called consultation process that started with the walkout in Port Alberni when the entire meeting rose as one and left McCarron and his cronies in the dark when he denied them the right to vote on mergers and councils.
Letter after letter sent to McCarron by members took him to task for ignoring their just demands for the right to vote and to natural justice. As a member of Local 1812 put it, "Let us choose a structure that is best for us on Vancouver Island. Bullying tactics will only weaken the union -- do not take away our historic right to decide what is best for our union." Another asked "Why will members stay with a union where they have no democratic rights?" Or as a member of Local 1989 put it, "Where on this planet can you improve your lot in life by giving up the right to vote?"
Despite being a small local, the Powell River carpenters have managed to organize at least 75 percent of the commercial work within their boundaries by local initiative and with some financial help from the Provincial Organizing Program. They firmly believe that "the way to make our organization stronger in this province is to build from our strength." Local 2086 members said, "It makes no sense to force mergers. We vote!"
The BC Provincial Council is appealing the General President's ruling both to the General Executive Board in Washington and to the BC Labour Relations Board and expects decisions very soon. The GEB is expected to rubber-stamp McCarron's decree, but the LRB, in the past, has ruled that mergers ust be subject to the express and informed vote of the membership and cannot be imposed from on high.

Island reflects Northern situation
Council appeals to BC Labour Board
by Doug McCorquodale

The situation on Vancouver Island, described above, parallels that of Northern British Columbia where two construction locals, Dawson Creek Local 1237 and Prince George Local 1998 entered into negotiations with each other to merge their locals. They agreed on a document and their respective memberships voted on the merger. A strong majority in each local voted for merger. The locals then applied to the International to get "the blessing."
Local 1237 is a construction local and also is certified by the BC Labour Relations Board to represent the trades people and grounds personnel in the Regional School Board. An hour's drive north is Local 2397, a school board local that represents teachers' aides, trades, crossing guards, secretaries, custodians etc. in Fort St. John. Local 1237, including its school board unit, voted to merge with the much larger local 1998. The President of Local 1237 is a school board unit member and a carpenter. The school board members of Local 1237 have an affinity with the construction Local 1998 because of their trade qualifications. They do not have an affinity with Local 2397 in Fort St. John which is mostly made up of teacher aides, secretaries, etc.
In addition, there is another factor that Local 1237 school board members considered in their decision to merge with Local 1998. An International representative services Local 2397. This same International representative (the only one who resides in BC) was servicing the Local 1237 school board unit until two years ago. The members became very dissatisfied with his services and discharged him as their representative. Local 1237 school board members do not look forward to getting him back by some back-door McCarron proclamation.
The International, after receiving a letter from Locals 1998 and 1237 requesting a verification of their merger, sent an International representative from Alberta who, without consulting any 1237 members, recommended that the construction carpenters in Local 1237 and 1998 be merged into one local and the school board members in Local 1237 be merged into Local 2397. The school board members of Local 1237 were angry that McCarron merged them into Local 2397 after they had voted to merge with Local 1998.
The right of members to vote on mergers is now the subject of litigation at the BC Labour Relations Board. The International opposes the right to vote, and Locals 1998 and 1237 and the Provincial Council of Carpenters support the right of members to vote. An injunction was granted against the International stating that no merger could take place until a decision was rendered by the Labour Relations Board.
Now we discover that the International violated this Board order by dissolving Local 1237 on the International Ultra computer accounting system, forcing the payment of dues for Local 1237 school board members through local 2397. This was a clear violation of the Board order and has the same standing as contempt in a court of law.
McCarron's past remarks about obeying BC laws are empty. When the Provincial Council confronted the International about this violation of the Board order, the response was that it was an inadvertent administrative error. Believe that? Got a bridge to sell you!

School Board Round Up
Most School Board Locals in negotiations soon
by Doug McCorquodale Local 1995 Vancouver
Local 1995 School Board unit together with the other trades settled their collective agreement with the Vancouver School Board. The bargaining unit is within the provincial government guidelines of Mandate II (0-0-2%) wage controls. The unit took this increase by way of improving vacation/time-off provisions
Local 2397 Fort St. John
The Local will be scheduling talks this spring as their contract ends in June. They are eligible for up to 2 per cent under the provincial guidelines, depending on the Board’s “ability to pay.”
Local president Agnes Aikins says they are trying to clean up the final details of the long struggle for pay equity. She is optimistic they will eventually get equity settled, and hopes the hard feelings generated by the six-year battle will soon dissipate.
Local 2545 Quesnel
Negotiations in Local 2545 are underway with the assistance of Provincial Council secretary treasurer Dave Flynn.
With legislated wage controls mandated under the Public Sector Employers Council, the focus of this round of bargaining has been the issues of job security, respect and dignity. A number of improvements to the collective agreement have been agreed upon but the main issue of contracting out remains outstanding.
When the negotiating committee reported back to the membership meeting in December, it was overwhelmingly decided to schedule a strike vote early in the New Year (January 13, 2000). At the same meeting, Sister Sandra Backer was elected as local president, replacing Sister Connie Anderson, who stepped down this fall.
Local 2106 Prince George
Prince George School Board unit entered negotiations with their employer last month. The bargaining unit is facing the second mandate of the wage controls issued from Victoria. This mandate allows for a three-year contract with zero per cent in the first two years and two per cent in the third year.
The other bargaining units in the school board district are preparing for litigation against the employer over Medcan, a subsidiary of an American firm. Medcan’s role, among other things, is to monitor absenteeism. The unions oppose Medcan’s methods as incursions on privacy.
Local 1237 Dawson Creek
The school board bargaining unit’s agreement expired last June. The unit is in no rush to re-enter negotiations as they had completed the last two-year round just last February. When they do enter negotiations they will be facing Mandate II (0-0-2%) guidelines. Local 1237, including the school board unit, is involved in litigation at the labour relations board with the International and School Board unit local 2397 in Fort St. John (See Council appeals page 1).
Local 2423 Hope-Agassiz
Negotiations will commence in the New Year. The last round of collective bargaining saw the merging of the two collective agreements following the amalgamation of the two school districts of Hope and Agassiz and their respective unions, the Carpenters and CUPE. In October the local membership voted down a dues increase. However the situation is so untenable that the status quo is unacceptable and a solution will have to be found.

First expulsion in at least 50 years say some
NorCal member expelled over wildcat protest

None of the BC Provincial Council of Carpenters members polled can remember ever hearing of a member being expelled from the Brotherhood for any reason, least of all for being involved in a mass action. Yet last month, a hand-picked UBC trial committee of two Americans and one Canadian ruled that John Reimann of Hayward CA Carpenters Local 713 should be drummed out of the organization because he led a short wildcat strike of union members centred around the San Francisco Airport project last May.

Reimann, charged by GEB member and McCarron supporter Mike Draper with not being "obedient to authority", was found guilty of encouraging members to express their dissatisfaction with an inferior four-year contract extension being rammed down their throats without a ratification vote. The unanimous verdict, signed by Americans Gerry Nannenga and Dennis Donahou and by Canadian Martyn Piper, the appointed Executive Secretary Treasurer of the Alberta Regional Council, indicates that "no strike" clauses acclaimed even without direct membership approval are more important than a member's democratic rights to "freedom of speech, association and assembly."

While recognizing that "divergent views are the lifeblood of the labour movement," and admitting that "it must never be the role of the Union to stifle ideas..." and pretending that denying membership to an existing member "is a somber occasion and is by no means entered into lightly for the sheer purpose of exercising power," the International reps decided that "Mr. Reimann's actions are not constitutionally protected" and he should be given the boot.

Testimony, much of which was hearsay, by several paid union functionaries at Reimann's trial indicated he helped organize the demonstration by some 2000 building trades workers who walked off the job to protest an employer friendly contract negotiated during a massive construction boom. Reimann is accused of speaking to workers from the back of a pickup truck, helping organize picket lists and sites, applying for a city demonstration permit that was subsequently denied, and publishing "certain documents" on the internet (purported to be encouraging the strike). Denials by Reimann's witnesses were dismissed out of hand with no explanation.

But the most damning accusation may be that Reimann refused to name names to the trial committee. In a statement that could have been lifted directly from infamous Senator Joseph McCarthy, the committee said Reimann's "failure to provide this relevant information (about the group called Working Carpenters for a Stronger Union) weighs heavily against him in this matter." Working Carpenters maintains a newsletter on the internet and is the Northern California group of Carpenters credited with spearheading the struggle for a democratic union in that state. Reimann said he refused to name members because Mr. Draper would use the information to "get" other people. Reimann said he is the victim of a conspiracy by the General Office to stifle all debate about the "disastrous policies that are dragging our union down and down and down."

What the top leadership is trying to do, says Reimann, is turn our union into an employment agency. "They want to simply be the middle-man between us and the contractors and have control over the sale of our skills as carpenters," he said. "In order to do this, they have to be able to guarantee the smooth and steady flow of our labour (as well as have near-monopoly control over it). along with this, they have to maintain 'good relations' with the contractors (If these good relations come at the expense of our working conditions and wages, well, that's just too bad for us)."

Reimann claims that the wildcat took away that control over the members' labour. "This meant that their fat wages and their position was also being challenged. We also shook up their 'good relations' with the contractors. My God, what could possibly be worse than that?"

BC Provincial Council president Len Embree told Reimann, "It is obvious to us in British Columbia that the memberships in both of our areas are involved in a struggle for the very basic membership democracy." He concluded, "It is indeed ironic that while your members are fighting to restore their right to vote, we are fighting to retain that right. In some ways, your struggle and experience give us greater inspiration to maintain our democratic rights."

A petition and donations and messages of support for Reimann are being organized by Working Carpenters for a Stronger Union at : PMB 258, 20885 Redwood Road, Castro Valley, CA, 94546-5015. Phone (510) 496-3458. Their newsletter can be viewed at: http://members.tripod.com/ubcvote/fallnews/fallnew01.htm or donations can be sent to the "Campaign to Defend John Reimann" PMB #421, 484 Lake Park Ave. Oakland, CA 94610.

Serious discontent in the union says Reimann
When 200 guys spontaneously walk off the job against their own union there is serious discontent, charges Local 713 secretary John Reimann. He explained that the wildcat walkout at San Francisco airport in May was a direct result of a leadership dedicated to "keeping the contractors happy."

Speaking to carpenters at several meetings around British Columbia in November, Reimann asserted that the trend to signing Project Labour Agreements, especially without membership ratification, is turning the union into a mere employment agency. He claimed that all PLAs have non-union working on them.

"The best PLA is a strong and united membership," he declared. "We must organize the non-union from below and we can only get that with enthusiastic participation of our own members." He said we will not get membership participation in organizing if they feel the leadership "is selling them down the river." "The policy of keeping the contractors happy is not working and can never work," he avowed.

Level Letters
Expelled member promotes links
Expelled member says brief trip to BC informative and educational

Editor:
I would like to thank the BC Provincial Council of Carpenters and its members for the hospitality you showed me during my too brief visit there recently. I found the trip extremely informative and educational and I only hope I was able to contribute something in return.

I think that what happened just a few days after my visit -- the mass protests in Seattle over WTO - perfectly illustrate what is wrong not only with our political setup, but also with the direction of our labor movement. the WTO is aimed at maximizing profits by increasing the competition between workers of different countries for who can work cheapest, who can offer the lowers tax rates (to the corporations), who will limit corporate polluting the least. In short, who will allow the corporations to rape, loot and plunder to their hearts' (or rather their bank accounts') content.
Unfortunately, too many of our labor leaders (McCarron included) have bought into this scenario and are signing their members up for this "race to the bottom," all in order to "keep jobs."
I look forward to members here in California linking up with you brothers and sisters in British Columbia to launch a campaign to reverse this direction.

Fraternally,
John Reimann Local 713
Hayward CA

Spotlight on organizing by Josh Coles, provincial organizer
Market Share a disastrous term for Union

This fall, John Reimann, the Recording Secretary of Local 713, Hayward, California, met with BC Carpenters Union members to explain his experiences both with General President Doug McCarron and with the UBCJA. Reimann is one of a growing number of members who are fighting contract concessions in California through job-site actions such as July’s San Francisco Wildcat Strike. McCarron is presently attempting to expel Reimann from the union for his beliefs. (see Reimann on page 2) Reimann and his supporters have formed the Working Carpenters for a Better Union. Below is an excerpt from a recent article that appeared in their newsletter. In it Reimann argues that the often-used term “Market Share” is nothing more than a scheme to lower all carpenters wages.
Until the late 1970s, the building trades controlled about 80 per cent of construction in the USA. When non-union construction started to increase, the unionized contractors went to the building trades leaders and told them that they had to help them compete with the non-union. Our own union leaders simply accepted this idea and repeated it to the membership. At first, many members accepted this idea also.
This meant that we, the union carpenters, had to compete with the non-union carpenters for who had to work cheapest. The entire purpose of having a union is to eliminate exactly that sort of competition.
Holding back our wages.
It was only after a few years of give-back conditions and wages while the non-union sector continued to grow that this became clear. And why shouldn’t it grow; after all, the non-union usually pegs its wages at a percentage of union scale: if we take a cut, they take one. Then we have to take another one, leading to a never-ending downward spiral.
Going along with this was the union leadership cutting the contractors all kinds of concessions to keep them happy. Did they violate the hiring hall? No problem; we’ll let them hire who they want. Did they fail to pay fringes on time? No problem; we’ll let them pay when they get good and ready (And if they fall far enough behind, we’ll even allow them to only pay part of what they owe and forgive the rest!). This was our leaders’ approach, and members are sick and tired of it. Every time they complained, they were told in one way or another that nothing could be done, so they got sick of going to union meetings.
As members got more and more discouraged, they increasingly lost confidence in the union and the contractors knew this. The contractors got bolder and bolder, and the non-union spread even wider.
The new slogan of ‘market share’ is nothing but a replay of this idea of helping the unionized contractors compete. The way we are supposed to regain market share is to hold down our wages and conditions.
“Valley Storm” and Work (Profit) Preservation
The whole approach totally undermines any serious organizing effort. How is the union to overcome the vicious repression and resistance of the contractors, especially in the Valley area? The only way they can do this is with the enthusiasm and power of an organized and active rank and file. But while the leadership talks about membership involvement, Volunteer Organizing Committees, etc., in practice they discourage membership participation through forcing rotten contracts down our throats.
So what do they do instead? They base their efforts on an appeal to the contractors to sign a union contract because it’s in their (the contractors’) best interests, not because their workers will go on strike and be backed up by the union carpenters, but because they can get a plentiful supply of not-too-costly labor through the Union. In the booming remodel industry in San Francisco they are offering the contractors a special contract for 80 per cent of journeyperson scale. Plant, Dome, Mayta and Jensen and other contractors who do this same work are also eligible for this contract. The only reason they don’t go for it is that they know they couldn’t get Carpenters to work for them at that rate at present. But in the next recession, they will be beating down the doors to get that contract.
A strong union.
The union should fight for the best contract with the best wages and conditions possible. The leadership should organize regular general membership meetings to explain why we need and deserve a $5 per hour raise, coffee breaks, full return of the black Fridays, job protection, a stronger hiring hall, etc. They should also explain that, to win and keep these things, we must see to it that all carpenters get them—in other words, organize the unorganized. The struggle for a good contract with good wages and benefits should be directly linked to the need to organize.
They tell us the opposite: to take cuts now in order to help regain “market share” so as to unionize the industry. Nothing could be better calculated to making the idea of organizing unpopular among the members, to discourage the members and weaken the union.

The full text of John Reimann’s article can be found in Working Carpenter on the internet at: http://members.tripod.com/ubcvote/fallnews/fallnew01.htm

Other internet news and views of interest to Carpenters Union members can be reached through the union website at: http://www.carpentersunionbc.com

Strike and Boycott information can be found at:
OPEIU vs BCAA http://www.bcaaonstrike.com
IATSE vs movie theatres http://www.bcprojectionists.com
BC Federation of Labour http://www.bcfed.com
CLC home page http://www.clc-ctc.ca
CEP Herald/Sun http://www.savetheherald.com

Support BC families
Don’t buy Sony Products
BC Projectionists, members of IATSE 348, have been locked out of their jobs for a year. Like most of us, they just want to keep their jobs to provide for their families.
But Sony won’t let them. Sony’s theatre chain, Cineplex Odeon, wants projectionists to take an 80 per cent wage cut. Sony took in $56 billion last year, but 61 BC projectionists haven’t been able to go to work for a year because Sony and other theatre companies want to make even more money.
The real objective of the theatre companies is to break the union. The projectionists and their fellow workers, BCGEU members who work in the theatres, need your support. A boycott of Sony products has been endorsed by the BC Federation of Labour and the Canadian Labour Congress.
Please boycott all Sony products and stay away from Famous Players or Cineplex Odeon theatres until this dispute is resolved.
BCAA strike in 11th month
Members of the OTEU who work at 10 BC Automobile Association offices in the Lower Mainland and Nelson have been off the job since early February seeking a first contract. BCAA has refused to negotiate the most basic principles, including the right of an employee to union representation, pay equity and seniority. The company has been found guilty of numerous unfair labour practices during the strike and still resists serious negotiations.
The BC Federation of Labour has declared a Boycott of all BCAA products and services.
“Our message is simple,” says BC Fed president Jim Sinclair, “Don’t use BCAA.”
He explained, “BCAA has to get the message that part of being a good corporate citizen in this province means showing respect for employees.” He added, “This strike is all about giving workers better protection and a decent standard in the workplace.”
Boycott National Post
The Canadian Labour Congress has authorized a national boycott campaign against Conrad Black’s National Post newspaper.
The boycott will put pressure on Black to settle the strikes at the Calgary Herald and Castlegar Sun, said CLC president Ken Georgetti.
“Black has drawn a line in the sand in Calgary against the labour movement by his use of strikebreakers and by his refusal to negotiate basic conditions—like seniority rights—that have existed in other newsrooms across the country for over 50 years,” Georgetti said.


Confident members will meet the many challenges in the new millennium
Members committed to trade union principles
our differences have historically been our strength

PRESIDENT’S CORNER by Len Embree

Another year of fun and frolic! One thing the year-end always produces is the opportunity to look back with perfect hindsight in evaluating our performance. We probably should have done some things differently and in future we probably will. Be that as it may, a bit of a synopsis of the past year is in order.
Restructuring—International style
After numerous statements about following the laws of BC, one of the latest fiascos perpetrated by the International has them transferring school board members from Local Union 1237 Dawson Creek into Local Union 2397 Fort St. John in defiance of an LRB order. When challenged by the Provincial Council, their response was, “administrative error.” Some performance, especially by a party that feels entitled to talk about “scruples.”
It remains fairly obvious that any dealings we might have with the General Office will be suspect from now on.
Despite the ruling from the Labour Relations Board that halted the forced merger of some Dawson Creek Local 1237 school board members into Fort St. John Local 2397, General President McCarron has gone ahead and decreed mergers on Vancouver Island, effective in the New Year. This is against the express wishes of the membership who decided in a province-wide referendum that no mergers should go ahead without the consent of the Local members in a democratic vote (see story on page one). The Provincial Council is appealing both these actions to the Labour Relations Board and expects a ruling very soon.
Bargaining
The Negotiating Committee continues to meet with CLRA. It is our intention to conclude a collective agreement as soon as possible. This may be problematic with the voting structure of the Bargaining Council; nonetheless, we are committed to carry through bargaining to its obvious conclusion.
Industrial Conference
The Industrial Local Unions’ Conference, held October 15-17, had increased participation this time. It was a very worthwhile conference with instructional workshops for the participants and a general session on the final morning. Workshops, presented by Capilano College, dealt with Labour Relations Law and Health & Safety Regulations.
Unfortunately, Brother Flynn and I were tied up in LRB meetings related to the International and were unable to participate fully. Hopefully, this will not be the case next year.
Education
Having had the opportunity to visit most of the Local Unions during the year, it was quite obvious to me that our members are well informed about most of the issues facing the organization. Some credit for this, I feel, should go to the Education Committee. We need to do more in this area, but the committee is doing good, positive work.
In General
At the halfway mark of my term, I have to say how impressed I have been by the commitment of our members to their trade union principles. I recollect the General Executive Board Member for the Tenth District, in one of his many missives, asking the question, “Do British Columbia members think they’re different?” Yes, I think we do. And I see absolutely nothing wrong with that attitude. It seems to me that our differences, right across our country, historically have been our strength. It has allowed us to develop different strategies to meet our different problems. Only a fool would suggest that we are all the same or that one solution can be applied to all problems.
I remain confident in our union in BC and in our membership to meet the many challenges upcoming in the new millennium.
On behalf of the Council, I would like to express our solidarity to all our members and their families and to thank them for their support. We look forward to that same solidarity and support in the coming year.

The School of the Americas
Thousands protest military school linked to torture and murder
by John Voykin
In November, I stood with over 12,000 other people outside the gates of Fort Benning, Georgia, calling for the closure of the School of the Americas. We held vigil for all the nameless, voiceless people killed in Latin America—many of them by graduates of the infamous military training school.
The School of the Americas, started 40 years ago in Panama to train Latin American military personnel, moved to Georgia in 1984. Graduates of the school have been linked to a long history of human rights abuses and atrocities in their own countries.
This protest marked the tenth anniversary of the 1989 murder of six Jesuit priests, their housekeeper and her 15-year-old daughter in El Salvador. Nineteen of the 26 soldiers indentified as the killers were graduates of the school.
More well known graduates of the school include: Panamanian dictator Luckovich, Manuel Noriega and Roberto D’Aubuisson, who planned and ordered the assassination of Salvadoran Archbishop Oscar Romero in 1980.
The US government and military swear they are training people in American values of democracy and human rights, yet the countries with the worst human rights records in the Western World have sent the most people to the SOA. Hundreds of thousands of men, women and children have been raped, beaten and killed. Most evidence points directly to the SOA.
The crowd was amazing: Church groups, Veterans for Peace, students from Universities and highschools, peace activists from everywhere, Buddist monks who walked 104 miles from Atlanta, First Nations and Labour organizations from throughout North America were represented.
The vigil continued on Sunday morning as more than 4000 people, myself included, crossed onto the base in a large funeral procession as many called out the names of people killed by the military. After each name was called, the crowd would call out “Presente” and lift wooden crosses up in front of them.
It was a very powerful weekend in my life for I had to forget about myself and be present for others who could no longer speak for themselves.
My most sincere thanks to Brother and Sister carpenters, the Union of Spiritual Communites of Christ, my new-found friends in Spokane Washington, for opening their home for me to sleep. To Paddy Inman, Ken Little, Bud, Sandy and Jack (my travelling companions) and everyone who supported me both financially and in their kind words and prayers. Peace and love be with you.

All the best in the New Year.
John Voykin Local 2300
Labor Unions that say "Close the School of the Americas"

Contractors move off position of hard cuts to agreement
COUNCIL COMMENT by Dave Flynn
Negotiations remain high priority for Council

In spite of the International’s restructuring agenda in BC draining much of the Provincial Council’s time, energy and resources, negotiations remain a high priority. Some progress has been made at the bargaining table over the past several weeks and it is possible the Carpenters could conclude trade talks early in the New Year.
At the outset of trade talks, the contractors were seeking many hard cuts to the collective agreement, including cuts to wages and benefits, the right to move their crews around the province, and the elimination of the sub contracting clause which would allow them to sub contract work, including work within the Carpenters’ jurisdiction, to non-union contractors. Generally, they were attempting to become more competitive with the non-union and CLAC contractors by negotiating an agreement that reflected the same types of wages and working conditions.
Following several bargaining sessions in November, the contractors finally moved off their position of hard cuts to the agreement. To accomplish this, the union had to agree to develop a more rigid and formalized enabling process. What is being proposed is language in the enabling clause that would oblige the union to participate in the enabling process if the union contractor was bidding against non-union or rat union competition.
Negotiations are now focused on developing enabling frameworks, or templates, for different geographic areas of the province. These frameworks would establish the basic enabled conditions for these regions and, providing there was non-union competition, the union would have to agree to the pre-established conditions. It is generally accepted that there are a number of different economies around the province and rates that may be competitive in the Lower Mainland may not work in the Okanagan. This approach would allow each region to establish an enabled rate that works for them.
In order to provide some checks and balances to enabling, it is being proposed that a sub committee of the Joint Advisory Committee would meet at least quarterly to review the record of enabling over the previous three months. This committee would attempt to identify what was working and what wasn’t in each area. It would be the stated purpose of the committee to increase the enabled rates over the life of the agreement whenever possible.
Although not perfect, this approach appeared to be the only way to get past the employer demands for hard cuts. The committee review will provide some protection against abuse of the system and continued talks throughout the term of the agreement would serve to improve union/employer relations.
If we are able to conclude trade talks in the near future, we will still have to wait for a number of trades in the Bargaining Council to settle their talks before the Bargaining Council can get back to the main table. Ultimately, there will be an industry settlement to take to the membership for ratification but this could take anywhere from several weeks to many months. In the meantime, the Carpenters Union will have to continue to find ways to address the problems in our sector of the industry.
Looking back, 1999 was a year of frustration and turmoil for the Carpenters Union in British Columbia. Our ongoing fight with the International, the collapse of the Portside project, problems between Locals, problems within Locals— nothing seemed to go smoothly this past year. But I am confident the New Year and the new Millennium will mark the turning of the corner for our Union. Here is to a New Year that will see us out from under the boot of the International, that will see a new agreement ratified, that will see the union market share increase and will see all our members working on good jobs at the rates they deserve. I would like to wish all the members and their families good fortune and good health in the New Year.


WTO — Not good for working families

After nearly 40,000 union members, students, community activists, farmers, religious leaders and environmentalists marched together in unity in the streets of Seattle, the Nov. 30 to Dec. 3 meeting of the World Trade Organization ended in disarray. Trade ministers and heads of state were unable to achieve any agreements, or even issue a final statement. “The breakdown reflects the first step in a serious coming to terms with pivotal issues—accountability, democratic procedures, worker and human rights and the environment—that protesters highlighted all week,” said AFL-CIO president John Sweeney. “It signals the beginning of a new era that recognizes the urgent need to construct a trading system that can face the challenges of the 21st Century.”
While the newspaper headlines and television coverage concentrated on the violence of a few, the vast majority of the marchers were there to make a peaceful point: WTO is not good for working families.
Forty busloads of protesters went from British Columbia to join the massive march. Participants from around the world, as far away as China, Japan and India, demanded the restoration and renewal of a civil society where human rights stand for more than corporate demands for unbridled profits.
Sweeney said he regretted that a few violent people had given the protesters a bad name. “We must not let the negative actions of a few overshadow the accomplishments of more than 30,000 positive and peaceful protesters,” Sweeney said.
In a demonstration of solidarity not often reported, the Longshore and Warehouse Union shut down the Port of Seattle and dozens of ports along the West Coast.
Carpenters were very much in evidence at the rally and march on November 30. Locals from around the area sent delegations and signs were spotted from Locals 131 Seattle, 247 Portland, 360 South Sound Residential, 1144 Seattle, 1532 Mount Vernon, 1797 Renton, 1995 Vancouver, 2205 Wenatchee, and 2396 Seattle Piledrivers. The BC Provincial Council of carpenters and the Vancouver and Nanaimo-Duncan Labour Councils were also very evident.
The World Trade Organization , a global body which puts corporate interests before human rights, environmental sustainability, labour security, public education, healthcare, democracy, and sovereignty, is the successor body to the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade.
WTO rules protect the rights of global corporations to make profits but provide no protection for citizens, workers, communities or the environment. When profits are threatened in trade disputes, the WTO issues rulings and enforces them with sanctions and penalties. The WTO provides no similar sanctions when human rights, labour standards or the environment are at risk.
What has the WTO cost us so far?
The WTO is forcing Canada to abandon many of the policies that have given Canada the highest quality of life in the world. So far, the WTO has ordered Canada to:
• Abandon the auto pact, the historic trade pact on which we have built a productive and competitive manufacturing sector.
• Start dismantling our agricultural supply management system which would force Canada to allow the import of food that does not meet Canadian food safety standards.
• Scale back supports for research and development in Canada’s high technology sectors.
• Gut our efforts to promote and preserve our unique cultural institutions.
The WTO wants new rules to give for-profit companies free access to our health care and education systems. In Canada, that would undermine Medicare and quality public education. Canada would be forced to allow for-profit global corporations into our hospitals and schools. A current US challenge under WTO rules would further limit Canadians’ access to affordable generic drugs. Another issue on the near-future bargaining table is restrictions on our ability to protect our water supply from foreign control.
The WTO represents the same failed approach to globalization that the Liberals tried to impose on Canadians with the MAI. As the successful campaign against the MAI showed, challenging the current direction of globalization requires the co-operation of citizens, progressive groups and elected leaders.

Skytrain caisson dwarfs piledriver

John Rilkoff stands inside 8’ diameter caisson for the Rapid Transit extension in New Westminster. Van Pile, Petrifond and Agra Foundation are using drilling equipment new to this area to sink the huge drilled piles for the first three milestones of the ALRT project. This is the largest project currently underway in the province.


WCB backs mould research
Local 1995 Carpenters recognized at awards ceremony
Twelve new research and training projects that will help to increase and improve the capacity to reduce workplace injuries and disease were announced by Workers’ Compensation Board Prevention vice-president Roberta Ellis at the WCB’s eighth annual Grants and Awards program celebration in December.
Finding Solutions to Workplace Injury and Disease, the WCB’s grant program, provides financial assistance to support early identification and prevention of workplace risks, research methods for reducing risks, evaluation of post-injury rehabilitation strategies, and promotion of effective education on health and safety risks.
Finding Solutions awarded a total of $609,267 to a cross-section of employers, unions and academic researchers to investigate the causes and factors contributing to occupational injury and disease, and to provide solutions to help rehabilitate workers.
Two of the projects focus on indoor air quality, including a study by the Carpenters Union to analyze the health risks and provide recommendations to protect construction workers working in restoring mould infested buildings caused by water penetration. The second will create test standards for measuring indoor air pollution in workplace environments such as schools.
A large number of buildings in BC’s Lower Mainland have suffered water penetration in wall cavities and other parts. This has led to extensive mould growth and exposure of workers to biologically active fungi and moulds.
In the Carpenters study, workers’ exposure to inhaled fungi and dust and their respiratory health will be measured. Control measures and personal protective equipment capable of limiting exposures will be recommended.
The study, being conducted by the University of British Columbia, will cost the WCB just over $50,000.
“We expect that the data generated by this research will be instrumental in reducing the risk of workplace exposure to toxic microbial substances,” said Vancouver carpenter Bill Duncan when accepting the award.
“With the passing of Bill 14, the Workers Compensation (Occupational Health & Safety) Amendment Act, the board now has the jurisdictional power to set work place standards where biological, chemical or physical agents pose threats to a worker’s health,” said Duncan.
He pointed out that there is a great demand for training in mould remediation around the province.
“The union has already begun to deliver the first of our worker focused mould remediation courses,” said Duncan. “We want to insure that the risk of workplace exposure to toxic microbial substances is neutralized.”
Ellis told the ceremony participants that, “We must continue to learn more about why and how workers are being injured or exposed to disease on the job. In the 10-year period from 1989 to 1998, work related accidents and disease claimed the lives of 1,482 workers. Death on the job due to accident or disease is devastating to families, friends, communities and co-workers. Equally tragic is that almost all of these accidents could be prevented.”
Other projects funded cover a variety of safety, prevention and return to work issues ranging from musculoskeletal injuries (sprains, strains and repetitive injury) to emergency drill procedures for fishers, to critical incident and post-traumatic stress disorders, to prevention of sexual assaults and harassment, to the health hazards of special effects in the entertainment industries.

Lost Lives: Work-related deaths in BC
Study shows too many make the ultimate sacrifice at work

The WCB has released a 10-year study of work related deaths in British Columbia to increase awareness of the reality of deaths on the job and to encourage action to eliminate workplace deaths. Besides some revealing interviews with surviving spouses and family members, the report outlines the statistics of hazards facing workers daily as they work to earn their livings.
The summary discloses that in the 10-year period from 1989 to 1998, work related accidents and disease claimed the lives of 1,482 workers; an average of 148 people each year (19 of them working in construction annually).
The death rate was highest in the Charter Air Services industry where the rate for the 10-year period was 21.5 deaths per 10,000 person years of employment followed by logging at 9.3 deaths, compared to an all-industry average of 1.04. Road Building and Related, and Building Construction, were sixth and seventh at 3.3 and 2.5 respectively.
In real numbers of real people, this represents 252 workers killed in logging, 126 in trucking, 104 in building construction, 94 in heavy manufacturing, 86 in road building and related, 59 in fishing, 53 in mining (not coal), 49 in charter air services, 45 at sawmills, and 41 in farming over a 10-year period.
Falls kill more than 10 workers annually.
In the 10-year study period, there were 104 fatal falls from elevations accounting for more than nine per cent of all single-incident deaths in BC. Workers who died as a result of a fall worked in a variety of occupations including roofers, construction workers, firefighters, window cleaners, and farmers.
The most common falling accidents were: falls from a building (21%), falls from a ladder or stairs (13%), falls due to a structural collapse or failure (8%), falls from a scaffolding or platform (8%), falls from a vehicle (7%) and falls from a floor or roof opening (4%).
Workplace disease
Work-related diseases claimed the lives of 379 people between 1989 and 1998, representing 26 per cent of all work-related deaths in the province. Asbestos exposure accounted for 52 per cent of these deaths. It is estimated that building construction workers compose 70 per cent of all workers exposed to asbestos and at risk of developing asbestos related disease.

BC Federation of Labour president Jim Sinclair said the report makes a significant impact. “The statistics and stories presented in this report paint a grave picture of the thousands of workers and families who have suffered the devastating emotional and economic hardships of a workplace death,” he said. “Worse still, we know these statistics do not tell the whole story.”
“Any workplace death is tragic and we must never forget that every one of these numbers represents a lost life and a grieving family,” said WCB Prevention vice-president Roberta Ellis. “Equally tragic is the fact that workplace deaths are preventable. Work-related deaths can happen to anyone. It doesn’t matter whether you are a farmer, a nurse, an electrician or a salesperson—no one is immune.”

Canadian Brickies apply for successorship rights in Ontario
by Doug McCorquodale
The Canadian Bricklayers are back at the Ontario Labour Relations board to deal with decisions rendered last summer when the Bricklayers International tried to impose a trusteeship on its Ontario members. In those decisions the Ontario board found that the International “acted without constitutional authority” in revoking Ontario local charters. In addition the Board found that the International “did not act reasonably and therefore did not have just cause” to revoke the charters. Since the International breached the Ontario Labour Relations Act, the Ontario Bricklayers are applying as the Canadian Bricklayers union to be the successors of the locals previously affiliated to the International.
The conflict between the Ontario Bricklayers and their International led to the creation of a new union, the Bricklayers and Allied Craft Union of Canada. The Ontario Board described the dispute as the “story of two different approaches to trade unionism” and the desire “by some for Canadian autonomy.”
The Canadian Autoworkers Union (CAW) applied for intervener status on this matter. CAW supported the right of International unions in Canada breaking away from their American parent union, stating:
“The issues on which the Board must decide are of vital importance to the bricklayers of Ontario and to unionized workers in general. The right of union members to democratically control their union is fundamental to the health of the labour movement and the continuance of the collective bargaining regime. The ability of Canadian workers to form unions that are independent from their American parent must be recognized as a legitimate and workable option—especially when the relationship between the American headquarters and its members in Canada has irrevocably broken down...”
The Ontario Labour Relations Act has good law that says an International American parent union cannot put a Canadian subordinate union under trusteeship without “just cause.”

Need help with Alcohol, Drug or Family Problems?
The Construction Industry Rehabilitation Plan is set up to assist you with any problems you may be experiencing with alcohol and other drugs, family or spousal conflicts, emotional dilemmas or any other areas of need.
Confidentiality is guaranteed. In no case will your name or circumstance be made public.
In most situations we can offer full or partial financial assistance.
We at the PLAN are here for you and your family—Confidential and Caring.
If you are experiencing any problems in any area, please:
Call the Plan Our number is 521-8611
toll free 1-888-521-8611
Creekside — built union, built right
Creekside at Silver Star, a condominium housing project union built by Concert Properties (formerly Greystone) situated next to the Silver Queen Chair on Silver Star Mountain near Vernon is ready for occupancy. Phase One, consisting of 52 units in two buildings is selling well according to local Concert representative Laura Gosset. The project, with its ski-in/ski-out capacity, is a “superbly designed, high quality resort condominium” built by union carpenters from the Okanagan, she says.
The stylish units, freehold strata title condominiums with no restricted use, range from studio apartments to two bedroom, two bath suites complete with kitchen appliances and natural gas fireplaces and are valued from $79,900 to $175,900. Owners can opt for a complete, ready-to-move-into furniture package if they wish. Creekside also offers a care-free rental management service if owners wish to rent the suite.
The superior construction and stringent standards of home building set by Concert ensure a lasting investment. Over the past ten years, Concert has become recognized as one of the leading residential and commercial development companies in British Columbia, synonymous with superior standards, customer service and community values—all built union.
Creekside, while next to a night lit chair lift, is also close to the village, the skating rink, and the tube park. When the snow is gone, trees and flowers bloom, and hiking, biking, riding, canoeing and climbing make Silver Star a family getaway. Festivals, shows, rallies and races entertain the summer visitor as well as BeerFest in the fall.
Vernon Local 1346 BA Tony Heisterkamp says more than 40 local carpenters worked to complete the project on time and on budget and that his members look forward to working on the next two phases that will see a further 104 units completed, possibly next year.
Vernon carpenters also look forward to winning work on the $10 million performing arts centre and $15 million arena approved in the November municipal referendum as well as the rumoured hotel work that may start at Silver Star soon, according to Heisterkamp.

Labelling plant votes to stay union
Union beats decert attempt
A solid majority of Carpenters Union members working in a glass labelling plant in Vernon have verified their faith in the union by turning down a decertification attempt, says Vernon Local 1346 business representative Tony Heisterkamp.
“Over 62 percent of the workers at Univeral Specialties voted to stay with the union after a concerted campaign by a few unhappy plant workers,” said Heisterkamp.
Plant management has been unco-operative with the union, and particularly Heisterkamp, since the Local won certification in May of 1998, refusing him access to the plant site. Universal is the only union glass labelling plant in the country.
“We filed some unfair labour practice complaints with the Labour Board that will be heard in mid-January,” said Heisterkamp, “and after that we can deal with tearing down the roadblocks to winning the hearts and minds of those in the plant who are not familiar with the union movement and how it can best serve their interests.”
There are a number of outstanding grievances Heisterkamp is anxious to deal with that have been hanging fire since the vote was taken and ballot boxes sealed on August 24, 1999.
“After the hearing (on the unfairs) we can get down to business on these long outstanding grievances,” he said.

Millwrights offer trades upgrading
Millwrights’ Local 2736 is continuing its program of offering state-of-the-art upgrading training for its members with the newest equipment and top-notch instructors.
Daniel Gidora has replaced the recently retired Paul Dugas as instructor. Gidora has a degree from BCIT in Survey Technology as well as an Interprovincial Industrial Mechanic certificate. Gidora has developed training manuals and assembled the latest advanced equipment for two new courses.
Rotalign
The Local sponsored eight 40-hour courses in Rotalign Pro Laser Shaft Alignment in six different communities around the province last year. The course accommodates a maximum of six students and uses the very latest technology available.
The Local purchased a $28,000 computerized Rotalign Pro alignment machine from Hyatt Industries at the end of 1998 for effective hands-on training. They continue to offer training on the older but more established Optalign laser alignment equipment as well as conventional methods of shaft alignment using dial gauges etc.
Mechanical Surveying
The introductory course in mechanical surveying has been changed from a basic construction survey course to one dealing specifically with layout and alignment in the mechanical construction sector. Equipment, methods and procedures used in mechanical surveying are covered using mockup machinery to create relevant job training. Participants use the Local’s own survey equipment along with some that Commonwealth Construction has generously loaned for the course. The course has been lengthened from one week to two weeks.
Blueprint Reading
A course in development for this year will cover blueprint reading and trade math, important background for all apprentices and journeypersons.
Gidora says the training program has been enthusiastically received by the membership. The courses have been well attended and feedback has been positive. He thanks some companies for their assistance in putting on the courses, especially I.I.C. in Prince George and MacIntosh & Norman in Powell River.
Millwrights at Rotalign course at MillPile hall in Surrey, from left: Tom Ridley, John Hammond, Norm Schymon, Patts Julien, Dan Gidora and Kurt Freiburghaus
In Memory
Labour movement builder passes
Eldon T. (Al) Staley
1917 - 1999
Al, to all who knew him, was a dynamic individual. His service to the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and his impact on the labour movement throughout British Columbia will long be remembered.
Born in Witchurch Township, Ontario, in 1917, Al Staley started his carpentry apprenticeship with Frank Deach in Siloam, Ontario, in 1936. After discharge from the Midland Regiment of the Canadian Army in 1945, he moved to Victoria on Labour Day 1946 and joined Local 1598 on October 21 of that year. He quickly became involved in Local affairs, accepting the position of financial secretary in 1948.
In 1950 he was elected president of the Vancouver Island District Council of Carpenters and in 1951 became the first full-time secretary treasurer of the BC Provincial Council of Carpenters.
He was a founding member of the Victoria Trades and Labour Credit Union and the Victoria Building Co-operative Union, serving on both Boards of Directors for 40 years and retiring as president.
In 1961 Staley was appointed a General Representative for the Brotherhood and in 1971 became the General Executive Board member for Western Canada, a position he held until his retirement in 1977.
Brother Staley served as president of the BC Federation of Labour from 1964 to 1970 and as a vice-president of the Canadian Labour Congress from 1966 to 1977.
According to CLC president Ken Georgetti, “Brother Staley was a builder of the very foundations that have made the British Columbian Labour movement the powerful and credible organization it is today.”
Even in his retirement as GEB member Al took on a new challenge to be the first umpire for the newly formed Jurisdictional Assignment Plan of BC. He stepped down from that position in July, 1979.
“Brother Staley was a tireless champion for workers and he will be missed,” said Local 1598 business manager Wayne Cox.
Brother Staley is survived by loving wife, Jennie, daughter Maureen, and granddaughters Martina and Linea.

Popular activist gone
Edward Cecil Brooke
1941 - 1999
Local 1735 Prince Rupert members will remember Ed Brooke as always racing against time to get the job done. He died in December after a short illness.
Ed was a carpenter, a draftsman, a logger, a fisherman, a teacher, a husband (several times), a father (at least 10 times), and a grandfather (twice) who used his many tal-ents to help his fellows and to try to create a better world for all.
He built boats and rowed some of them, studied and replicated Victorian architecture, dabbled in archeology, anthropology, furniture and wine making, restoring historical buildings and antiques, model railroading, playing classical music, teaching navigation and advocating for the less fortunate.
Ed served the Local as a business agent for a short time and was the North West’s representative on the Carpentry Apprenticeship and Training Committee.
Ed Brooke went North from Nanaimo twenty some years ago, mostly to fish, but joined Local 1735 in 1989 and immediately became involved in Local affairs, serving as area steward and financial secretary before his short stint as BA. He was also a staunch defender of Canada’s claims to the Northern Boundary with the US and served on the auxiliary coast guard. He was active in the Masons and an energetic contributor to local parish life. He claimed a personal acquaintance with left-wing activist Angela Davis.
His ten children, Guy, Cynthia, Deirdre, Julian, Leif, Eva, Jules, Erik, Olava and Ingrid, and wife Pat and granddaughters Erin and Kathlyn were all with him at his passing and will miss his compassion and good humour, as we know many others will.

ON THE LEVEL is dedicated to representing Carpenter's Union member's views and reporting on social issues of interest to working people in British Columbia.

ON THE LEVEL, the newspaper for Carpenters in British Columbia, is owned and operated by ON THE LEVEL PUBLISHERS LTD., which maintains editorial offices at #304-2806 Kingsway, Vancouver, BC, Canada V5R 5T5, telephone (604) 430-8140. Fax 437-1110. It is printed at Broadway Printers, Vancouver. Annual subscription fee $10.00 in Canada, US $10.00 in the USA. Active members pay $9.60 per year through their Carpenter's Union dues.

Editor: Ray Tickson.
Members of the editorial board are: Len Embree, David Flynn, Jane Richey and Brian Zedrilic.

ON THE LEVEL is a member publication of the Canadian Assoc. of Labour Media (CALM) and the International Labor Communications Association (ILCA)

posted on the internet at www.carpentersunionbc.com


this page last updated 3/15/02 CUBC home page